Photos of tactile overly and addition app with carrying and text

Tactile to Digital Part 5: Addition and Subtraction

Understanding the spatial layout when regrouping and carrying in additional and subtraction problems using a digital game.

This is the fifth post in a series of how to successfully teach 21st Century classroom skills by pairing tactile graphics with digital resources. In this post, we will discuss using a tactile overlay on the iPad (app also available in Google Play!) to introduce the spatial layouts of adding and subtracting with carrying and regrouping. Adding and subtracting requires that students be able to apply tech skills such as being able to drag in a straight line across rows and down columns in order to add/subtract the correct numbers. Understanding the spatial layout is also critical, especially when carrying or regrouping is involved. Please see the previous posts in this series as they provide foundation skills that lead to solving digital math equations. 

The Math Melodies app has a series of progress math-related games. The Math Melodies Addition and Subtraction games are the first digital math app that has created an accessible way to regroup and carry within the app. In this video tutorial, Jessica demonstrates the Math Melodies Addition equations under the First Grade Advanced level. These addition problems are laid out as vertical equations, most of which require carrying. The First Grade Advanced Subtraction problems are also laid out as vertical equations, most of which require regrouping.

Prior to solving these equations, students should be familiar with 0-9 math facts, should understand ones, tens and hundreds columns, and should have experience in dragging a finger up/down a column in a straight line. 

Note: The First Grade Base level has 1-digit equations (ones column with simply carrying). While the First Grade Advanced equations have 2-digit addition problems (ones and tens columns). In the video tutorial, Jessica demonstrates the First Grade Advanced level in order to show how to solve equations that may be slightly more complex.

Pre-Teach the Spatial Layout

Review the braille version of a similar addition problem; discuss the ones and tens columns, where the answer goes (at the bottom of the equation) and where the carrying number is placed (at the top of the number). Think about having blank boxes to indicate where you input the answers and carrying numbers.

Photo of 3 digital addition equations: a digital equation in the Math Melodies app, a braille equation and a print equation in a math workbook.

For some students, Pre-teaching the skills using the tactile graphic (before placing the graphic on the iPad) is preferred. Typically, this method is used with students who are distracted by VoiceOver speaking or who cannot keep their hands still. For most students, introducing the tactile overlay on the iPad is preferred, as VoiceOver provides verbal information as to what the student is touching. For many students, having the built-in verbal information available when using the digital addition and subtraction problems – especially when paired with the tactile overlays – increases the student’s success in solving the equations and builds solid spatial concepts required for more complex math problems.

Initially focus on learning the spatial layout of the entire page using the tactile graphic. The tactile graphic has empty boxes for the equation, carrying, and answers “equals”. It also has the smaller boxes with brailled answer choices along the bottom of the page and symbols for the buttons down the right side of the page. The buttons are the Back button, Quit button (quit this game) and Listen button (Read Aloud option for students who are not using VoiceOver). Have the student systematically explore the entire tactile graphic for the digital equation. What is different between the braille version and the tactile overlay graphic? How many rows of empty boxes are there and why? Where do you input your answer? Drag your finger down the ones column. Drag your finger down the tens column. Note: The app calls the top row of boxes the “carry” boxes and the bottom row of boxes the “equals” boxes. Note: The tactile overlay has bolder lines around the “carry” boxes and “answer” boxes, to indicate that you can input numbers in these boxes.

If pre-teaching, verbally say an equation. (Example: 65 + 8). Ask the student to repeat the equation. If introducing the tactile graphic on the iPad, confirm the numbers in the math problem by touching the very top of the screen (VoiceOver will announce the equation again.)  Where does the first number go in the empty boxes? Where does the second number go? Find these numbers in the actual equation.

If your student has a good mental image of the equation, ask him/her what he/she will find if he/she drags his/her finger down the ones column? (Example: The student should remember or learning to build the mental image: 5, 8, “equals” box). Repeat with the tens columns – what will you find? Then confirm by dragging your finger down the tens column. (Example: The student should remember or learning to build the mental image: “carry” box, 6, blank, “equals” box.)

Teacher’s Note: It is strongly recommended that the student drag around the screen and not right/left swipe. Right or left swipes will move through the boxes from left to right. Up or down swipe will NOT move up or down a column! (Up or down swipe will change whatever the rotor is set on.) When dragging, use a split tap to activate an “equals” box, carrying box or answer box.

Note: In the app, the smaller answer boxes do not appear until you split tap on an “equals” box. Navigate to the desired answer and split tap to select the desired answer. The answer will automatically be added to the selected “equals” box.

Photo of Math melodies math addition equation and the tactile overlay with empty boxes.

Listening Skills

When a new page opens with a new equation, VoiceOver announces the math problem. Example: In the video tutorial, the first problem is announced, “How much is 73 + 6?”  This is key information! The student should instantly develop a mental image of this equation, remember the numbers, and refer back to this mental image while solving the problem! In his/her mind, the student should visualize the vertical equation, lining up the “3” and “6” in the ones column and the “7” in the tens column.

Addition Problems

After listening to VoiceOver announcing the equation and developing the mental image of the vertical equation, the student can confirm the numbers if desired or he/she can search for the ones column and start solving the equation. The student can confirm by dragging down from top, center of the screen to find the first number (in the photo below, the equation is 54 + 96; with 5 in the tens column), then drag right to find the ones column (in this case the 4). Some students do initially need to confirm the spatial layout by touching each individual number in the equation. However, this is not as efficient as simply touching the equation at the top of the page. If the student only needs to confirm the numbers in the problem – not the spatial layout – the student can touch the top of the screen to hear VoiceOver announce the full equation again.

Teacher’s Note: Ask the student to say the equation before touching the screen! If the student is struggling to solve the equation, ask him/her periodically to say the equation and the steps as he/she solves the equation. Saying the equation is basically helping the student to think aloud, which helps not only the student process the steps, but also provides the teacher insights to the student’s thinking process. When introducing this app, often it is helpful to model the thinking process by having you – the teacher – say the steps out loud when either modeling the process of solving the equation or when guiding/introducing the student through the process the first time.

Solving the Addition Problem

Once the student has the equation firmly in his/her mind, solve the equation by:

If the answer required carrying:

Repeats steps as needed to add the tens column and then hundreds column.

In the video below, Jessica demonstrates how to use the tactile overlay with an addition problem and a subtraction problem in the Math Melody app. In this demonstration she includes how to carry and how to borrow/regroup.

Editor’s Note: The process of carrying and borrowing sounds more complicated than it is! When solving the problem in braille, the student has to roll the paper up and down in the braille writer and line up the brailler embosser head in order to place the carried number or regrouped number above the equation. With the digital format, the student simply drags his finger to the desired box and split taps, then selects the desired answer from choices at the bottom of the page.

Editor’s Note: In the video, Jessica demonstrated subtraction regrouping in the ones column and completing the ones answer before she crossed out (“slash” as the app calls it) the tens column. Often the order is to cross out the tens, add the new number in the “carry” box above the crossed out number, then change the ones number by adding the original number in the ones “carry “box, then select “Add ten” answer choice button. (Example: In the video example, 63 – 15, 6 is crossed out to make 5 and the 3 becomes 13.)

Subtraction Problems

When introducing the subtraction problems in the Math Melodies app, follow the same strategies listed above for introducing the addition problems. Be sure to compare the braille format with the tactile overlay on the iPad! Instead of “carry” box above the tens column, there are now “regroup” boxes above the tens and the ones column. The first number in the tens column also has the option of “slash on” which means that the number has been borrowed from.

Photo of a subtraction problem in the Math Melodies app that requires regrouping and the tactile overlay for 2 digit subtraction.

After the student is familiar with the tactile overlay, the spatial layout, then solve the problem. In the picture below, the equation is 63 – 15. You cannot take 5 away from 3, so you must borrow 10 from the number in the tens column. 

When regrouping, find the number in the tens column that you will borrow 10 from. 

Completed 63- 15 = 48 subtraction problem with the 6 in the tens column crossed out and a 5 above and regrouped 13 placed above the 3.

Tactile Overlays for Addition and Subtraction

A big thank you to Transcribing Mariners who have donated the embossable graphics work for the Paths to Technology Resource Library and this blog post. A huge thank you to Jessica McDowell, TVI extraordinaire, for sharing her work on bridging the gap between tactile graphics and digital resources!

Related Posts Resources 


Attached File(s)
By Diane Brauner

evaluation checklist form

Instructor evaluations and low vision

Student fingers on the Monarch. APH's photo.

Making math more accessible: Monarch’s Word processor

simple nature picture with digital grab handles to enlarge the picture.

How to create high resolution images for users with low vision